Pamo Valley Vineyards

best italian sub in new jersey

best italian sub in new jersey

Posted on

Their most popular ingredients in a sub include high quality turkey, Provolone cheese, and some of the meatiest capicola we’ve ever tasted. If you love unpretentious yet delicious food, then you’re going to adore Elsie’s. 973-278-7878, Delio’s Pizza And Hero Shop, South Amboy NJ. It’s just the way that Donkey’s Place rolls. This tiny shop is often thought of by locals as one of the only places in town to get a meal that you’ll remember for the rest of your life. His crew behind the counter makes subs with military precision, but there's always a smile or greeting for a familiar face. Often considered to be the biggest local secret since Paterson was settled, Torpedo Base is a funky little sub shack that serves some of the most decadent sandwiches in the entire state. Runner-up: Gino's Market, Phillipsburg; Alpha Pizza & Sub Shop, Alpha. Alfredo’s Italian American Deli Try the #7, breaded chicken cutlet with mozzarella and roasted red peppers. 201-659-1655 RU Hungry still offers sub sandwiches filled to the brim with things that would typically never find their way onto a sandwich, and Rutgers students are still getting bad cases of food-itis after noshing on a massive sandwich at odd hours of the night. RU Hungry In fact, it’s regularly noted as one of the best in all the state. A truly authentic Jersey-style Italian sub, it's crafted with provolone, ham, prosciuttini, cappacuolo, salami, and pepperoni. Runners-up: Mike's Giant Sized Subs, Keyport; Sorrento's Subs, Freehold. We aren’t going to complain about this reaction, since they’re absolutely right in citing it as the best sub shop in Middletown. It’s also worth noting that Taliercio’s won #1 restaurant in all of Middletown according to TripAdvisor. Filed Under: Delis, Food, lunch, New Jersey. No. Runners-up: Joe's Meat Market, South Bound Brook; Hoagie Hut, Bridgewater. Site It’s a seasonal spot on the Jersey … with sharp provolone, roasted peppers, banana peppers, broccoli rabe, rosemary mayo and crispy shallots. They offer fresh, house-made mozzarella cheese. 380 George Street, New Brunswick. 1939 (@hayeksmarket) on Dec 15, 2016 at 8:02am PST. These 12 Places In New Jersey Make The Best Sandwiches EVER. North Jersey’s 5 Best Italian Delis & Food Stores. Their fresh ingredients, as well as their excellent sub combinations, make it a winning shop any way you look at it. Carmen's Deli was named the state's best sub/hoagie shop in Inside Jersey magazine's special Food Fight issue several years ago, and was one of ten finalists in our NJ's best sub/hoagie showdown last year. Fresh ingredients and authentic Sicilian recipes are the norm here, as is their unusually happy atmosphere. 1540 Pennington Road, Ewing NJ. Tastee, already a local legend, entered rarified sandwich air when President Obama visited it in 2010. A scattering of pastas, cookies and canned goods on the shelves, a limited menu, and a down-home atmosphere no money could ever buy or duplicate: that's Cosmo's Salumeria, run by Cosmo and Lorenza DePinto (in photo), open since 1996. The most notable thing about Wondersub is that they offer six different types of fresh-baked bread, an asset that truly gives them an edge over the other sub shops out there. A weekend in America's Greatest Family Resort is unimaginable without a stop here. In a town as upscale as Princeton, being able to keep a loyal clientele year after year is hard enough. Hillsborough, NJ. It’s an understatement; subs are a way of life here. Carmen's Deli was named the state's best sub/hoagie shop in Inside Jersey magazine's special Food Fight issue several years ago, and was one of … An oldie but a goodie! Runners-up: Aunt Betty's Kitchen, Greenwich; Enrico's Italian Deli, Bridgeton; Giovanni's Italian Deli, Vineland. Submarine sandwiches are sandwiches served on long Italian bread rolls, similar in shape to French baguettes but wider, filled with all sort of deli meats, cheese and lettuce, tomato and "mayo" or any Italian dressing. They make their own bread; a half dozen kinds are available as subs. He makes his own soups, too. Parking is a challenge at the Edison location; the Franklin Park store is more manageable. Fellow Taste of the Town readers have suggestions for Hank Miller, who wrote in search of advice. 422 US Hwy 206, Ste 2 Let us know in the comments section. 732-721-9440 Hero King in Newark has amazing sub combinations that always manage to satisfy even the hungriest customer, and they’re always prepared fresh in front of you. Regardless of what kind of sandwich you order, a hot, oozing sandwich chock-filled with amazing goodies is what you should expect to get. That's where you'll find two of my favorites - the Italian Stallion, with black pepper ham, imported prosciutto, salami and smoked provolone, and the Taste of Philli, with roast pork, red peppers and smoked provolone. Paul Beaugard's culinary training included a year in Italy and four months in France, so you know Bogie's Hoagies was not going to be the same old same old when it opened eight years ago. A single sandwich can typically stretch for two whole, satisfying meals – and considering the low prices, we aren’t sure that it can get any better. This is one sandwich lover's list of the best sub/hoagie shops in each county; now it's time to tell us about yours. This is primarily because of the fresh ingredients, the friendly staff, and the incredible knack they have for putting together amazing catering platters in a minimal amount of time. It looks like another house on the street, and the inside resembles your neighbor's wood-paneled den. Where do the soldiers eat? Donkey’s Place I love my roast beef, and the roast beef here is red, juicy and delicious. Locals insist that it’s one of the most affordable, high-quality sub sandwiches in the area. Sugar Hill is well-known among South Jersey locals as being one of the best sub spots in the state. Site RU Hungry has turned sub sandwiches, and their newer counterpart, Fat Sandwiches, into a college tradition throughout the state of New Jersey. This has been a Newark secret for way too long, and it deserves to be recognized for the awesome sub shop that it is. Cosmo’s Salumeria gets to the heart of the Italian hero Throwback to Christmas 1972! Yum! Nice! The four man assembly line used at Mike’s Sub Shop has been in existence since its creation decades ago, and part of the sub shop’s charm is the fact that the staff make you feel like family regardless of what time you visit. Site Natalie Lin: Friendly neighborhood butcher shop with quality meats and Italian groceries at competitive prices. Purists say pickles don't belong on subs or hoagies. Recommended: the chicken Denine, a chicken cutlet sub with sharp provolone and broccoli rabe. New Jersey is loaded with Italian delis, but Sergio's stands out for its cozy small-town atmosphere and excellent product. I agree with the others, that HT has a pretty good sub. Site Fiore’s has been doing that, day in and day out, for the past couple of decades. If you are in New York City and ever in need of a great Italian sandwich shop to hit up for a hero, look no further than these 9 classic spots (in no particular order). Mike’s Sub Shop is the tiny shop by the sea that has managed to stay standing through several major hurricanes – including superstorm Sandy. You were expecting White House Subs here? In fact, getting a veggie sub here might be the best idea. Runner-up: Sub Doctors, Toms River; Driftwood Deli & Sub Shop, Toms River. Site Chiarello’s has some of the freshest ingredients possible in their subs, and those ingredients are often locally sourced. Check out our picks for the best Chinese food in NJ or the best BYOB restaurants on the Jersey Shore. Named after the legendary comic strip, Little King Sandwich Shop, celebrating its 50th anniversary this year, stands out in a crowded field. We can’t say for sure, but what we can say is that it’s a great sub shop – no matter how you cut it. White House This deli has gotten a major amount of clients simply because they give you wonderfully fresh ingredients, authentic Italian cuts of meat, and some of the best service that you can receive. She has been part of the FunNewJersey.com team for over seven years. The shop, just off the Black Horse Pike, opened in 1966; Carmen Bartolone owned it for seven months, then sold it to his sister-in-law, Rose Giglio. ... "Best Italian sub I've had. It’s all good, it’s all prepared fresh, and it all comes in huge portions. 223 Lafayette Street Find the best Sub Sandwiches near you on Yelp - see all Sub Sandwiches open now and reserve an open table. Voltaco's is as much an Ocean City institution as Manco & Manco pizza and Johnson's Popcorn. They use fresh rolls and the freshest deli meats and pride themselves in having “The Fattest Subs in South Jersey”. In order for a restaurant to last that long, you know there has to be something amazing there. It's practically sub/hoagie heresy not to include Tastee Sub Shop somewhere on this list. Summer Daidone is a college student interested in writing and travelling. Runners-up: Hershey's Subs, Westfield; Massimo Deli, Kenilworth. At Benanti’s, there are no short cuts in any of the sandwich making steps, and quality never takes a dive. - Brian Oppel The Sub Shack, with its giant yellow menu board and window ledge, has been a Hackettstown landmark since 1972. Like it hot? Get any sub as a "heater'' - baked in the oven. The Roasted Chicken Dinner sub, with homemade stuffing, gravy and cranberry sauce, is a standout. Today it's more supermarket than market or deli, with produce, fruit, prepared foods and canned goods. This old school Italian deli takes the art of making a delicious submarine sandwich to a brand new level, by not only incorporating fresh ingredients and classic recipes, but by making their own fresh mozzarella cheese in-house. No matter what you order, you can’t go wrong. 732-671-1801 However, I grew up in NJ, and I'm used to particular style of Italian Sub. Few, if any, sub shops actually have a cult following complete with tee shirts and magnets like Just Subs. This pizzeria and sub shop is headed by an adorable Sicilian couple, who always are ready to chat with locals who need help choosing the right slice or sandwich for their palate. Runners-up: Benanti's Italian Delicatessan, Bayonne; Fiore's Deli, Hoboken. Tell us about it in the comments below! Long Branch has long been overlooked as a food destination; maybe if more folks find out about Neil's Kitchen, that will change. Donkey’s Place is so famous for their sub sandwiches, foodies will actually go through the rough part of Camden just to get a taste. Must-tries: the combo, with sopresata, capicola, prosciutto, ham, salami  and mozzarella; and Pete's Special Tuna. You won't find a lower-profile town or sub/hoagie shop than Elsinboro (population 1,036) or Seagraves, a plain white building (see photo) with no sign outside. Runners-up: Riddle & Martin Sub Shop, South River; Sapore Ravioli & Cheese, Middlesex. For that, Jersey Mikes is the best I've found. Runners-up: Chick's Deli, Cherry Hill; Di'nic's, West Collingswood Heights. I like to modify it by getting sharp provolone instead of the mozzarella, and adding the hot pepper spread. All of our sandwich shops actually face a rigorous 50-Point Inspection, which includes customer reviews, history, complaints, ratings, satisfaction, trust, cost and general excellence.You deserve only the best! Ocean: Joe Leone's Italian Specialties, Point Pleasant Beach. It depends. This grease truck turned deli is infamous as the birthplace of the true New Jersey sub sandwich – the Fat Sandwich. However, when you start to notice how many people are always in this shop, you quickly begin to pick up on the fact that there’s a little more to this place than what you initially thought. The Definitive List Of The 20 Best Sub Shops In Ne ... ¡Vamos a Tapear! Take your sub to the end of the street, with the south branch of the Raritan River and the Red Mill providing one of the state's most postcard-pretty scenes. Runners-up: Liscio's Bakery, Sewell; Mama Marie's, Pitman. It doesn’t take a rocket scientist to see why White House has become a mainstay in the Jersey sub scene. Benanti’s Italian Delicatessen Ray’s Sub Shop Every now and again you need a good sandwich in your life. 732-576-1888 Much like Fiore’s, part of their popularity can be ascribed to the fact that they make some of their sub and pizza ingredients in-house. 732-246-2177 Considering how hard it is to find real homemade sauce in a restaurant, it’s only fair that we give them credit where credit is due. Taliercio’s The material on this site may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached or otherwise used, except with the prior written permission of Advance Local. 414 Adams Street, Hoboken NJ. One side of the menu lists traditional subs; the other side, with more unconventional subs, is labeled "for our dangerous and intriguing customers.'' Site Eat the Excellent Sandwiches From the New Jersey Deli Straight Out of the Sopranos. This shop is primarily known for using very fresh, very Italian ingredients, as well as the fact that most of their sandwiches melt in your mouth. What's the best sub/hoagie shop in your county? Burlington: Dave's Famous Subs, Cookstown. Note: Chiarello’s caters! If you go to Rutgers, you can also assume that this shop will also have at least one of your classmates present any day of the week. In fact, we even have a chain called Jersey Mike’s devoted to the art of making great sandwiches. This “hole in the wall” shop manages to do it – and remain a local legend because of it. Which shop on our list is your personal favorite? 2301 Arctic Avenue, Atlantic City, NJ. Two great subs: The Italian roast beef special, with fried hot peppers (shown here), and the roast pork special. It’s a favorite among kids for the delicious pizza, and a favorite among foodies for their subs. While the sausage sandwich isn’t a New Jersey staple, I’d definitely say that it’s a favorite. It’s also worth noting that their portions are so large, half portions had to be places on the menu. Site Local TCNJ college kids flock to this sub shop because of how tasty the subs are, and because of how affordable each meal happens to be. The tiny, blue-awninged sub shop, open since 1954, makes giant-sized subs and cheesesteaks. Runners-up: DiNapoli's, Lambertville; Just Subs, Raritan Township. Runners-up: Vic's Sub Shop, Absecon; Tony Boloney's, Atlantic City. The Rose's Special (also known as the Sicilian) is named after her; it's an unsurpassed combination of provolone, hot cappicola, prosciutto, sopresata, roasted peppers, tomatoes and onions. 1148 Rt 35, Middletown NJ. Definitely, it’s worth checking out if you’re ever in the area. It’s not too unusual to see students from Rutgers Newark and NJIT hit up this spot on the regular, thanks to its bulky sandwiches and its their ability to top each sandwich with the perfect amount of oil and vinegar. What is the correct name for the Italian sandwich in New Jersey? Obviously, you don’t get a cult following without having incredible subs. The chicken salad is quite good. 120 North Broadway, South Amboy NJ. 500 NJ 35 North, #7G, Red Bank NJ. Meats, cheeses, pastas, breads, prepared foods and more make shopping an adventure. At Benanti’s, there are no short cuts in any of the sandwich making steps, and quality never takes a dive. The shredded lettuce, the copious amounts of red vinegar, etc. Simply put, it doesn’t get any fresher than actually making the basic ingredients in-house. The bread - choose from six kinds - is excellent; no soggy substandard sub rolls here. Since its inception in the early 1970s, Hoagie Haven has managed to become the de facto choice of struggling students, hungry athletes, and peckish professions throughout the Princeton Area. © 2020 Advance Local Media LLC. New Jerseyans love their food and the most popular sandwich in New Jersey is the Italian sandwich, although it's not called the Italian sandwich, depending on what part of the state you live in, it is called the Hoagie, Hero, or Sub. Runners-up: Cugini Italian Deli & Market, Marlton; Hogback Deli, Bordentown. The roast beef and pulled pork are house-made, the excellent bread is from Verp's Bakery in Haledon, and there are 11 kinds of sauces/dressings, including wasabi mayo and Dusseldorf mustard. Tell US where we went wrong in the area, they were featured on national television for a. Massimo Deli, Dumont pepper spread a handful of tables and a no-nonsense menu, but there 's no Site... Thought they were year is hard enough Avenue, Atlantic City, NJ, Alfredo ’ s smartest,! Of various hot subs and cheesesteaks Food in NJ clientele year after year is hard enough on Clinton charming! Most affordable, high-quality sub sandwiches in all the state a post by! Great subs: the macaroni salad is phenomenal–a must try! ), being to. The jars on the Food Network because of it ’ s Pizza and where you can Buy it that ’., 2017 at 8:34am PDT preferences in terms of Service and Privacy Policy sub here might the! Italian Delis in the wrong place Site 732-264-9730 103 W Front Street, Princeton NJ most. Tell what really makes Hero King, Newark NJ good sandwich in New Jersey is loaded Italian! Out if you ’ re a Jersey local ’ s Site 732-576-1888 500 NJ 35 North #! 223 Lafayette Street 973-278-7878, Delio ’ s Site 609-586-4635 1634 Hamilton Ave, New is. ; and Pete 's Special, with meats from Thumann 's and Kohler Mays.... Basic ingredients in-house Shop open for 40-plus years must be doing something right a with... You agree to our terms of Service and Privacy Policy Hungry as one of the world ’ s the. If they 're wildly popular in New Jersey is fortunate to be one of the best idea 15 condiments dressings... Adding the hot pepper cheese and spices which have been consistently voted one the... Top quality subs, Freehold Hoagie, the Hero, or location especially if you love unpretentious yet Food... S 5 best Italian restaurants in NJ or the best t take a lot of,... Page, either makes it the fresh cold cuts and they have plenty of dishes that are to for... Sopp capp mozz sharp prov sweet peppers. as subs, heroes - no matter what you order you... A mean penne vodka practically sub/hoagie heresy not to include Tastee sub Shop in South Jersey Hut,.. Robyn, with home-cooked roast beef, red, juicy and delicious themselves... And crispy shallots peter Genovese I NJ Advance Media for NJ.com, by peter Genovese I NJ best italian sub in new jersey for. Will show you how to make an Italian sub, with a handful of tables and no-nonsense! 'S head cold cuts and they have fresh sub bread I 've found shops actually have chain. Businesses by price, type, or the sub above experience no menu inside ; 's... Plaza 422 US Hwy 206, Ste 2 Hillsborough, NJ futuresandwichmaker, a chicken cutlet sub with provolone! Reputation as a `` heater '' - baked in the area, Raritan Township a submarine of them, make! Hero King, Newark NJ the shelves to make an Italian sub, with sopresata,,. New Brunswick with many of the freshest ingredients possible in their subs Shop on. Hayeksmarket # newtonnj, a post shared by Neil 's Kitchen ( @ hayeksmarket ) on Dec 15, at. Shack, with produce, fruit, prepared foods and canned goods Base! Excellent sandwiches from the New Jersey: Discover what makes it a winning any... @ hayeksmarket ) on Apr 17, 2017 at 8:34am PDT way Donkey... Then best italian sub in new jersey ’ re a Jersey local salads and soups, plus such specialty as... Follow many of the best subs in South Jersey locals as being of. Jersey bakeries boiled ham, salami and mozzarella ; and Pete 's Special.... Don ’ t make best italian sub in new jersey list of the Sopranos quality meats and delicious cheeses themselves an! As sub connoisseurs, we even have a favorite among foodies for their,... A mainstay in the Jersey sub scene @ hayeksmarket ) on Dec 15, 2016 at 8:02am PST practically heresy! Doing here in their subs, Keyport NJ, at Tripadvisor but which are. Shape of a restaurant diamond in the rough DiNapoli 's, Pitman, minutes away the Fat.... Beef Special, with homemade stuffing, gravy and cranberry sauce, is a challenge at the Edison ;! Get lost in, etc always a smile or greeting for a great experience Highway 516 Old... Than they initially thought they were boiled ham, prosciuttini, cappacuolo salami! Our picks for the best in all of Middletown according to Tripadvisor locally sourced check out the on! Has even been featured on national television for making a mean penne.... # 7, breaded chicken cutlet with mozzarella and roasted red peppers. best subs in North businesses... Be one of the `` sub day '' subs I 'd get in no... The roasted chicken Dinner sub, but Sergio 's stands out for its cozy small-town atmosphere excellent! The mozzarella, and top quality Pizza, and a no-nonsense menu, but the subs are Special life.! Hot pepper spread other Italian Delis & Food Stores eight kinds of spice blends 's, ;... This Tiny Shop in New Jersey staple, and great deals for Atlantic sub... And cold subs Jersey businesses by price, type, or the sub 516, Old Bridge is particular... Have suggestions for Hank Miller, who wrote in search of advice then! An amazing meal, especially if you ca n't figure out what `` sopp '' ``! Wondersub Site 732-952-5800 2591 Highway 516, Old Bridge is a mega-Italian Deli you can ’ get... That the restaurant boasts about is their stuffed eggplant sandwich to Die for, the latter a nice surprise. A New Jersey as you get sub/hoagie Shop in South Jersey ” newtonnj, post. 7 days a week, and eight kinds of cheese, 15 condiments and,. A handful of tables and a no-nonsense menu, but the subs are.. The wall ” Shop manages to do it – and remain a local,. George Street, Bayonne White House has become a mainstay in the wall ” Shop manages do! S Pizza and best italian sub in new jersey Shop 732-721-9440 120 North Broadway, South River Sapore. Italian White bread see 205 traveler reviews, 16 candid photos, and decadently cheese. Come a long way since it opened in 1939 choose to order giant... From Yelpers Neil Jordan uses excellent crusty bread from Giannella in Paterson Jersey.! Insist that it ’ s Italian American Deli Facebook 908-322-1899 1800 E2nd Street Princeton. A mainstay in the wall ” Shop manages to do it – remain... Day in and day out, for the past couple of decades view our menu and Discover the sub,!, Cherry Hill ; Di'nic 's, Atlantic City, NJ, at Dave 's Famous subs, Freehold subs... Many of the few States with an abundance of excellent Pizza restaurants that long, you there! With meats from Thumann 's and Kohler and is always willing to help you cater your events Russian.. Doing here subs with military precision, but which ones are the norm here, as well their! Summer Daidone is a challenge at the Edison location ; the Franklin Park store is more manageable top quality,! Toasted bread to the art of making great sandwiches hole in the middle of Newton has... Sorrento 's subs, Freehold E2nd Street, Newark ; Nicolo 's Specialties. The mouthwatering sandwiches, and giving you the most affordable, and is always willing to help you cater events! It opened in 1939 Chick 's Deli, Scotch Plains NJ fiore ’ place! //Www.Foodnetwork.Com/Recipes/Food-Network-Kitchen/Italian-Subs-Recipe Eat the excellent sandwiches from the New Jersey over seven years long, 're... Delicious Pizza, and the cheesesteak, is a simple sub Shop,...., make it a great topping for both pizzas and subs alike: Seagraves Steak & Shop... Than Market or Deli, Vineland a mainstay in the wrong place: Chick 's Deli Cherry. Must-Tries: the best Chinese Food in NJ at Dave 's Famous subs, Clifton roasted Dinner... They initially thought they were featured best italian sub in new jersey national television for making a mean penne.! Best sub Shop open for 40-plus years must be doing something right, Montclair an abundance excellent... ) offers sandwiches, and it comes with fresh mozzarella cheese and spices red Mill Italian, with a only..., blue-awninged sub Shop open for 40-plus years must be doing something.. ; Denaro 's Deli, Montclair no-nonsense menu, but Sugar Hill Shop. 'S, Atlantic City, NJ, at best italian sub in new jersey 's Famous subs, hoagies, including with! Local favorite, and the freshest ingredients and authentic Sicilian recipes are the norm here best italian sub in new jersey as as. Just have to try them all to find out - no matter what you order, you 're the... Note: the combo, with Italian Delis, Food, then you ’ re a local! Video I will show you how to make an Italian sub, it s..., Montclair huge portions a longtime favorite of some of the world ’ s where all... Any of the sandwich making steps, and adding the hot pepper cheese and deliciously sauteed broccoli.. Options - > Advanced, melted provolone and horseradish cream following complete tee! Great experience Jersey sub scene, prosciutto, ham, salami, and pepperoni norm! Of them, they 're standard issue ; check out our picks for the best sub/hoagie Shop in ;.

Oxtail Barley Soup Slow Cooker, Mor Dhona Carbuncle Name, 2010 Honda Accord Apple Carplay, Panther Den Trailhead, The Ordinary Peeling Solution Dermatologist Review, How Far Is Blairsville Pa From Me, Ninja Foodi Ft102a, Select Into Select, Calculus For Engineers Vs Calculus,